2001: an LA odyssey

ARLIS/NA 29th Annual Conference

Session 11: The Accreditation of Art Libraries: Benefit or Burden?
Tuesday April 3, 2001

2:00 p.m.-4:00 p.m.

Moderators:

  • Paul Glassman, Director of the Library, New York School of Interior DesignClayton Kirking, Director, Adam & Sophie Gimbel Design Library, Parsons School of Design
  • Clayton Kirking, Director, Adam & Sophie Gimbel Design Library, Parsons School of Design
  • Robert Craddick, Head Librarian, Pacific Northwest College of Art

Sponsors:

  • Art & Design School Library Division; Standards Committee; Architecture Section

Abstract:

Museums, schools of art and design, schools of architecture, professional degree programs, liberal arts colleges—many subscribe to the pursuit of excellence and the establishment of standards through accreditation programs. These usually begin with self-studies and assessment programs, leading to a presumably objective evaluation by a committee of peers. Achievement of accreditation can be a vehicle for quality assurance and accountability. How would the art library benefit from an independent accreditation process? Would accreditation help the art library achieve parity with academic divisions and curatorial departments? Raise the level of recognition paid art libraries? Provide assurance of adequate budgets and other resources? Guard in general against the marginalization of the art library? Help intensify commitment by the institution to the mission of the art library? Or, would accreditation introduce an unwelcome requirement of reporting and record keeping? Impose guidelines that may not acknowledge the nature of the particular library? Subject the library to arbitrary interpretations of its services and collections? Detract from the provision of essential services?

Museum Accreditation as a Self-Study Tool, Harold B. Nelson, Director, Long Beach Museum of Art

How can the American Association of Museums' accreditation process be explored as a potential model for art libraries?  Combining an internal self-assessment with an external peer review, the AAM accreditation process has been of great assistance to museums as both an evaluative and a planning tool.  Hal Nelson will discuss AAM accreditation from the perspective of a member of a visiting committee as well as that of the institution undergoing accreditation.

NASAD Evaluations of Art and Design School Resources,Thomas Ferreira, Professor of Art Emeritus, California State University, Long Beach; visiting team member, National Association of Schools of Art and Design (NASAD)

NASAD, the only accrediting agency covering the whole field of art and design, recognized by the U. S. Department of Education, considers the art/design library to be an essential and integral component of an accredited institution.  This talk will provide a brief discussion of NASAD’s standards for evaluating library resources consistent with the expectation that each institution shall have library and information resources necessary to fulfill its mission, goals, and objectives, and that they be appropriate for the size and scope of its operations.

FIDER Standards for Information Resources in Interior Design, Janice Stevenor Dale, FIIDA, CID, JSDADesign

High levels of achievement in an institution are interdependent with its resources and facilities. In this information age, including the wealth of art libraries in the accreditation review is central to demonstrating an institution's ability to deliver quality informational resources. The common body of knowledge of interior design is highly reliant upon visual currency and theoretical text.

NAAB Accreditation and Standards for Information Resources in Architecture, Katherine Diamond, FAIA, Siegel Diamond Architecture

Ms. Kate Diamond will address the key role of the information professional in the accreditation process and the importance of enrolling faculty in collection development and in maintaining information resources to support overall program goals.

Guidelines for Visiting Teams: The Experience of an Architecture Librarian with NAAB Accreditation, Elizabeth Douthitt Byrne, Head Librarian, Environmental Design, University of California, Berkeley

Tips offered to librarians on working with their own administrators to plan for an accreditation review, and to visiting teams on what to look for and what questions to ask during their review of a library.

home back to Tuesday | back to QuickFinder
last revised 3.16.01